Skip to content

Operations

Cutting return-to-origin on cash on delivery

RTO is the quiet tax on Pakistani ecommerce. It rarely shows up in a revenue dashboard, and it is usually the difference between a profitable store and a busy one.

By TezCommerce · · 7 min read

Cash on delivery is not going away in Pakistan. In many categories it is still most of the orders, and telling customers to prepay is not a strategy, it is a way to lose them. So the question is not how to avoid COD. It is how to stop paying for parcels that come back.

What a returned parcel actually costs

Store owners tend to think of an RTO as a lost sale. It is worse than that, because a lost sale is neutral and an RTO is negative. You pay forward shipping, you pay return shipping, the stock is out of circulation for a week, it frequently comes back unsellable, and you already spent acquisition budget to generate the order. A single returned parcel on a Rs. 2,500 item can easily cost Rs. 700 to 900 all in.

At a 30% RTO rate (entirely normal for an unmanaged Pakistani store), that cost is not a rounding error. It is often the entire margin.

Confirm before you dispatch

The single highest-return intervention is also the most boring: contact the customer before the parcel leaves. An automated WhatsApp message with the order summary and two buttons, confirm or cancel, sent within fifteen minutes of the order, filters out a meaningful share of the impulse orders, the wrong addresses and the people who ordered the same thing from three stores to compare.

A cancellation at this stage is a good outcome, not a lost sale. You have avoided both shipping legs and kept the stock. Count it as a save rather than a loss, or you will be tempted to stop doing it.

Fix the address at the point of entry

A large share of failed deliveries are not refusals, they are addresses the rider could not find. Pakistani addresses are genuinely hard: block, sector, phase, street, nearby landmark, and no postcode discipline. If your checkout has one free-text box, you are collecting whatever the customer can be bothered to type on a phone.

  • Split the address into structured fields: city, area, block or sector, street, house, and a separate landmark field.
  • Make the landmark field prominent rather than optional: it is what the rider actually uses.
  • Validate the phone number format at entry, and require a second contact number for high-value orders.
  • Offer a Google Maps pin drop. Adoption is lower than you would like, but the orders that use it almost never fail.

Know your failure pattern before you generalise

RTO is not uniform, and the instinct to apply one blanket rule is what keeps it high. Once you have a few hundred orders, break the rate down by city, by product, by order value, by traffic source and by time of day. The patterns are usually stark and specific.

Discount-code traffic tends to return more than full-price traffic. First-time buyers return more than repeats. Orders placed after midnight return more than orders placed at lunchtime. High-value orders return more than low-value ones. Certain cities return more than others, for reasons that are usually logistical rather than cultural.

Once you can see the pattern, you can act on it selectively: require advance payment or a partial deposit only on the segments that actually fail, rather than punishing every customer for the behaviour of a minority.

Make prepayment worth choosing

Do not force prepayment. Price it. A 5% discount for paying by JazzCash or EasyPaisa costs you less than one RTO, and it moves exactly the price-sensitive customers you most want to pre-qualify. Show the saving as a number at checkout rather than a percentage: Rs. 125 off is more persuasive than 5% off.

A realistic target

Confirmation flows, structured addresses, segmented rules and a prepayment incentive each remove a different kind of failed delivery, so they work best together. Driving the rate to zero is not realistic without turning away genuine customers; the aim is the point where the margin works. Track it weekly, by city and by product, so you can see which change moved it.

Start a project

Let's work together.

Tell us where you want the business to be in a year. We will tell you how we would get you there, what it would cost and how long it would take, in writing.